Do clocks tick you off?

In his book Confessions of an Advertising Man, originally published in 1963, David Ogilvy calls this ‘the best headline I ever wrote';

An advertisement written by David Ogilvy for Rolls-Royce in 1959

 

Interestingly, in a footnote he adds: “When the chief engineer at the Rolls-Royce factory read this, he shook his head sadly and said “It’s time we did something about that damned clock!‘“”

I previously explained that the ticking of a timekeeper is the sound of the escapement stopping a wheel tooth.  But why is the ticking of a clock music to some and unbearable to others?

Loudness is a common complaint.  The farther and harder the tooth drops before it is stopped by the escapement, the more energy is lost to sound and the louder it will be.  This will tend to increase with size, but energy loss can be minimized with an efficient design and good construction.  Also, the rest of the movement and its case can act to either attenuate or  amplify the sound.

The timbre of the sound can be soothing or grating.  Just like the character of a violin is much more than the pure tone of its vibrating string, we are not hearing just the escapement – the construction of movement and case all contribute to the texture of the sound.

Another aspect is the timing of the ticks – the beat of the clock.   An uneven beat probably offends everybody.  If, instead of an even “tick tock tick tock tick tock”, you hear “ticktock…   ticktock…. ticktock…” (or even tocktick!) then your clock is out of beat.  To fix this, make sure the clock is level, otherwise your repairer can easily sort it.

Some examples;

A platform lever escapement - brisk but pleasant. Seen here (as typically) fitted to a 19th century French carriage clock and still used in most mechanical watches. Carriage clocks are louder than watches because the escapement is bigger. I once heard one 20 times bigger again (in an experimental clock) and it was probably the loudest ticking I have ever heard!

A deadbeat escapement - dead quiet. Typically used, as seen here, in regulator clocks. Although larger than the carriage clock escapement, it is also very efficient and also the sound is deeper and the beat slower - all in all more restful. Here in a solar-sidereal regulator by John De Lafons in London c.1780 (British Museum No. 1998,0704.1)

The case and dial of the De Lafons clock


A verge and crownwheel escapement with short bob pendulum - a brisk and relatively noisy combination. Here in a longcase clock movement by Ahasuerus Fromanteel, London, c.1665 (British Museum No. 1958,1006.2099)

Some clocks were designed to reduce escapement noise.  Some of these had so-called “silent escapements” in which more compliant materials were used (such as spring steel and gut line) to absorb the impact.  Pietro Tommasi Campani invented an impact-free crank escapement for use in his night clocks.  Avoiding escapements altogether, compartmented cylindrical clepsydrae were recurrently popular at various times in history.  In quartz controlled clocks, the escapement is also eliminated, although many of those use physical hands whose driving motors can usually be heard, ticking or whirring.

A silent crank escapement - very nearly silent! Here in a night clock made by Pietro Tomasso Campani, Rome, 1683 (British Museum No. 1958,1006.2128)

The case and dial of the Campani night clock

A compartmented cylindrical clepsydra, made by Arnold Finchett, London, c.1760. This “water clock" is effectively silent. The drum rotates and descends, driving the hand. Inside the drum, water passes between compartments, controlling the rate of rotation.

 

Thanks to Peter de Clercq for inspiring this post and providing the piece on Ogilvy. 

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Do clocks tick you off?

  1. Peter Bunting says:

    The grass hopper escapement is pretty quiet. I made one to fit a rescued ‘Vienna regulator’ some 30 years ago and during the day you cannot hear it. During the evening there is a gentle “plop … plop … plop” as the pallets fall onto the springs.

  2. Mike says:

    There is something very restful about the ticking of a clock. I have three mechanical clocks in this room, all with a pendulum. My French mantel clock is inside a cabinet, and cannot be heard except when it strikes on the bell; an ex railway clock on the far wall is ticking quite quickly, while the longcase clock next to me, has a slow tick which reminds me of the slow, but inexorable march of time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>